Microsoft delivers a blow to open source with Visual Studio 11

Microsoft has already ruffled more than a few feathers with the exclusionary potential of its forthcoming Windows 8 operating system, and this past week the open source community has been up in arms again.


Microsoft has already ruffled more than a few feathers with the exclusionary potential of its forthcoming Windows 8 operating system, and this past week the open source community has been up in arms again.

The cause this time has been its Visual Studio 11 product line, new details about which the company published earlier this month.

Specifically, it looks like the free, Express version of the upcoming new product - widely used by many developers to create open source desktop applications for Windows - will no longer offer support for desktop-style applications. Rather, users of Visual Studio 11 Express will only be able to develop Metro applications.

Metro only

"Visual Studio 11 Express for Windows 8 provides tools for Metro style app development," notes Microsoft's Visual Studio website. "To create desktop apps, you need to use Visual Studio 11 Professional, or higher."

Visual Studio 11 Professional, of course, is far from free, with its US$499 price.

Microsoft's Visual Studio 2010 Express products will still be available for free download, the company notes, but they lack a number of key features coming to Visual Studio 11, including improved standards compliance.

Another version called Visual Studio 11 Express for Web will focus on HTML and JavaScript websites.

Meanwhile, to make sure there's no cheating, the Windows SDK for Windows 8 no longer ships with a complete command-line build environment, Microsoft says.

A strike against open source

Now, it's no mystery why Microsoft would want to push developers towards Metro, apps for which will obviously play a key role in the adoption of the forthcoming OS.

Taken in conjunction with the Secure Boot restrictions that appear to be on the way in Windows 8, however, it's hard to see this latest move as anything other than a strike against open source software.

Bottom line? Microsoft may be pledging new allegiance to open source, but such steps are a bit difficult to take seriously when moves like this are happening at the same time.
2 Comments
nzlemming@gmail.com It's actually hard to see this as anything other than Microsoft shooting themselves in the foot. On the one hand is Steve Ballmer screaming "Developers! Developers! Developers!" and on the other is marketing saying "Not so fast, kemo sabe!". An OS is nothing without developers. And developers will do it the way they want, not the way MS wants. And if that means no longer developing for Windows - well, there are other OSes. I can't see this as a "blow to open source" but I can see it as a boost, as more developers discover the freedom of developing for Linux and other systems.
Posted by Mark at 17:50:11 on May 28, 2012

Flag abuse

nzlemming@gmail.com Completely agree, Mark. I can't imagine how MS managed to become successful. They seem to careen from execution failure (Kin? WinPhone7?) to foot-shot. If I was an MS shareholder, I'd be *face-palm* right now. Now more developers will realise how much better Linux is than Windows for development in any case.
Posted by Dave Lane at 9:30:42 on May 31, 2012

Flag abuse

CURRENT ISSUE
Newsletter & Subscriptions Windows vs. iOS vs. Android:
How to choose the best tablet for you

101 great websites:
You haven't heard of yet

DIY desktops:
We ask the pros for building tips

SIGN UP
PC World's weekly round-up of tech news, gear and game reviews, software selections, and handy How Tos.
Blogs
Hot Products

Hot Products || PC World editors iPhone 4S launch pics and unboxing
The iPhone 4S launched at midnight through both Vodafone and Telecom. ... READ MORE

Tux Love

Tux Love || Geoff Palmer Google : Starting to be evil?
Google recently deleted AdBlock Plus from its Android Play Store. This is ... READ MORE

Tech Guy

Tech Guy || Juha Saarinen Small balls of solder
The idea that desktops might change forever is enough to send geeks into a ... READ MORE

In a Nutshell

In a Nutshell || Zara Baxter Logging, not login
At an event in Singapore yesterday, Seamus Byrne, the editor of CNet ... READ MORE

Harley O'Gyver

Harley O'Gyver || Harley Ogier Pay for internet by-device? Not on my watch.
So as those of you who follow my twitterstream will know, I'm currently in ... READ MORE

The Arcade

The Arcade || PC World editors New Year, new games
You'er going to laugh. Or at the very least, you're going to scoff and ... READ MORE

Dumb Terminal Live!

Dumb Terminal Live! || PC World editors New Zealand memes: We think we're real funny
We New Zealanders love the internet, and we have a pretty good sense of ... READ MORE