Review: Dell Inspiron 17R Special Edition
The Dell Inspiron 17R is a 17-inch (43cm) laptop which, for many users, would happily serve as a primary home PC.
Product type: Laptop
Editors rating: User rating:
RRP incl GST: $1,799
- Intel Core i7-3610QM CPU, 6GB DDR3-1600 RAM
- NVIDIA GeForce GT 650M, 2GB GDDR5 video memory
- 1TB 5400RPM HDD (no SSD)
- 17.3-inch, 1920 x 1080-pixel display
A great value proposition if you need graphical and computing power more than portability.
The Dell Inspiron 17R is a 17.3-inch (43cm) laptop which, for many users, would happily serve as a primary home PC.
Since the introduction of Intel-inspired thin-and-light ‘Ultrabooks’, we’ve given a lot of attention to laptops that aim to squeeze as much performance as possible into a very lightweight, portable package. The Inspiron 17R is the antithesis of the Ultrabook concept: it’s big, and uncompromisingly heavy at 3.28kg.
For reference, that’s the approximate weight of a newborn child, or an M16 rifle. Heftier than comfortable, but I guess you learn to carry one around if you have to.
The laptop sports silver plastic trim and a matte-black plastic base. The lid and keyboard surround/palm rest are aluminium, finished in a black honeycomb pattern. The silver trim and charcoal-plastic screen surround look tacky in my opinion, but the rest of the design is appealing.
The 17.3-inch screen is full HD, at 1920 x 1080 pixels for a dot-pitch of approximately 127ppi. That’s fairly average for a 17.3-inch laptop screen, and better than most desktop monitors – most 23-inch models are limited to the same1920 x 1080-pixel resolution. Compared to the latest MacBook with its Retina Display it’s laughable, but the same can be said of any other laptop available today. Certainly, 1920 x 1080 is far better than the 1366 x 768 most commonly found on models with screen sizes 15-inches and under.
The screen has an almost-matte, anti-glare finish that provides minimal reflection. It’s a nice change from the ultra-glossy screens of most laptops, and combined with its high maximum brightness, makes the Inspiron 17R well suited for use in strong daylight. Yes, you can play Minecraft, watch YouTube, and sell your worldly goods to pay for faster broadband, all outside under the comforting glow of the day-star. An important point, with summer only a few months off.
Play Minecraft, you say? Why, that’s a great point to segue into performance territory. Given a massive form factor and aforementioned ‘weight of a newborn child’, Dell had a lot of room to squeeze in high-performance hardware and cool it adequately to maintain that performance for more than a few seconds at a time. Obviously it was ‘good decision day’ when the Inspiron 17R was specced, because that’s precisely what Dell did.
Inside the 17R is an Intel Core i7-3610QM: a quad-core beast of a processor from Intel’s third-generation ‘Ivy Bridge’ range of Core i CPUs. HyperThreading gives it a total of eight concurrent threads. The base clock is a reasonable 2.3GHz, and individual cores are capable of clocking up to 3.3GHz thanks to Intel’s ‘Turbo Boost’ technology, as long as there’s sufficient thermal headroom to do so.
Our version had 6GB of DDR3-1600 RAM, notably faster than the DDR3-1066 or -1333 we’ve been seeing in Ultrabooks.
Graphics are handled between the CPU’s on-board Intel HD Graphics 4000 engine (thanks to Ivy Bridge, now DirectX 11 capable), and a dedicated Nvidia GeForce GT 650M with a whopping 2GB of dedicated GDDR5 video memory. The GT 650M is a killer card, giving us the highest overall results in our graphically-intensive benchmarks we’ve ever seen from a laptop. If you feel like doing some fairly serious laptop-based gaming, but don’t want to be obvious about it with an Alienware or ROG machine, here’s your chance to be sneaky without paying in framerate.
‘Oh, no Boss, that’s my work machine. It’s for spreadsheets. And Microsoft Word. Galactic Readiness Screen? Oh, that’s a new marketing simulation. For marketing. I have no idea who Commander Shepard is, I must have logged in wrong.’
I’m just seeing what I want to see, on the gaming side. This is not a gaming laptop, however it lends itself to the use. Design, 3D work, video editing, the usual ‘creative’ applications Dell pitches the Inspiron series toward are the key tasks here, and it shines in that area too. CPU-intensive benchmarks are also the highest we’ve ever seen from a laptop, with anywhere from 30 to 100% higher performance than other models we’ve tested in Cinebench and 7-Zip.
Results in all-around test suite PCMark 7 were good, but held back by the machine’s 1TB 5400RPM hard drive. Ultrabooks have made SSDs common, and set scores in storage-dependent tasks that mechanical hard drives just can’t match. That was the only disappointment we found performance-wise: if the 17R had featured an SSD as primary storage, or even as a cache, to a faster 7200RPM hard drive, the thing would’ve been a weighty rectangular dreamboat.
Performance means nothing if the machine is unusable, but the 17R is pleasantly easy on the hands.
The full-sized island keyboard includes a numeric keypad, making smart use of the available space (something I wish Apple would do with the larger MacBook Pro models). Key travel is fairly deep and keys have a quiet but clear ‘click’ on activation, giving a comfortable typing experience at anything from hunt-and-peck speeds to a furious hundred-plus-WPM dash.
At 4.5 inches (11.5cm) diagonally, the touchpad is larger than most smartphones. It’s both responsive and accurate, which is frighteningly rare among laptop pointing devices. The two discrete click buttons at the bottom work well, though a little more travel would improve their comfort, particularly when dragging.
Connectivity is pretty good: four USB 3.0 ports, no old legacy 2.0 ports wasting space. All 3.0 ports are backwards-compatible anyway, so anything less feels like a rip-off to me. Separate headphone and microphone sockets, full-sized HDMI output, VGA output, Ethernet port, SD card reader and a tray-loading DVD writer/Blu-ray player.
You should have figured out by now that I liked the Dell Inspiron 17R. Sure, it didn’t look as sexy coming out of the box as the sleek alloy-cased Ultrabooks I’ve been working with lately, but its power and performance won me over. Power, performance, and the fact that the model we tested retails for an amazingly reasonable $1,799.
Okay, that’s not a ‘budget’ figure, but performance laptops we’ve tested previously have come in a thousand, even two-thousand dollars higher. Here, you’ve got a ‘desktop replacement’ laptop with multimedia content-creation and gaming ability, priced the same as weaker-performing yet infinitely more portable Ultrabooks. You’re free to make an informed choice based on portability vs. power, rather than price.
Here’s a hint: if it’s power you’re after, the Inspiron 17R is a pretty good deal.
I have the same laptop but with a 7,200 rpm hard-drive. For price to performance- this is probably the best you can get currently. I have played crisis at high settings in full screen mode and it runs the game smoothly.
You are also right about this looking like a normal laptop- it's far from it- it can handle graphics excellently.
Also, by adding a solid state drive, this machine can be a monster. I plan to add one in the nearby future when i have more money.
Btw, thanks for the review, it's the best and most honest review of this laptop on the internet.
Posted by Vishal at 11:21:03 on September 12, 2012
Pros: Powerhouse performance
Cons: Fingerprints easily on surface- needs cleaning regularly.
Pros 4.5 Stars
The most impressive thing about this laptop is the components inside (as the saying goes- who you are in the inside matters the most- this is very true for this laptop)
Here is the model I have
Impressive high-end processor- 3610qm
Impressive gt650m graphics card
8 RAM great at 1600mHz
Nice big HD screen
7,200 rpm 750gb hard-drive
Depending on how strong you are, it is not as heavy as others have suggested. I'm not the strongest person you will meet but it shouldn't be a problem to carry this around with the correct bag.
Impressive built-in skull candy speakers- very nice base and tones- the best I've heard from laptop speakers
Price to performance = best on market.
The surface is prone to fingerprints. It needs regular cleaning- but i don't mind. Laptops should be kept clean anyway- just gives me an excuse to clean it more.
I can't complain much about this laptop for the price I paid for this, I couldn't really get anything better. If I was to buy a similar spec I would have to pay #1500 or more.
The laptop looks very humble, it looks like a normal laptop, but it can handle and play intense games like crysis easily.
The laptop looks aesthetically pleasing. I have recieved compliments that it looks nice. It's not something that looks like leonardo de vinci would have made but its pleasing to look at and to type with.
Posted by Vishal at 4:56:14 on September 13, 2012
Everything in the original review is true - you do get a lot of quality internal components for your money, and at first I was reasonably happy, though I did notice immediately that the screen wasn't as crisp and clear as my 2009 model HP Elitebook (admittedly a high standard to aspire to).
However two things went wrong.
The first, relatively trivial thing was that after placing my order I got a call from an overseas call centre and the person tried to tell me that the delivery address I had given "wasn't a residental address". (N.B. they hadn't tried to deliver it, just checked the address electronically by some means). Technically this was true, but irrelevant. I explained to him that I live out in the country, am never home during workdays and it's a considerable inconvenience and expense to get things delivered there, so I keep a physical delivery address in town at a mail agency where someone is available (and authorized) to sign for packages on my behalf and I pick them up when it suits me.
I have had this arrangement for years and received hundreds of packages, large and small without a single hitch, but this just didn't match the bureaucratic boxes that had to be ticked at Dell. I spent about an hour arguing with the guy and eventually managed to persuade him, but it delayed the order by several days and was very frustrating.
The second problem was more serious. I noticed after a couple of days that every time I rested my hands back on the keyboard after mousing or being away from the computer, there was a small but distinct *click*. I eventually traced it to the fact that when the screen was adjusted to be comfortable for me (6' 3" tall) the front right-hand foot was lifted very slightly off the table! Barely a millimetre, but there was light between the desk and the foot. A shorter person would have the screen at less of an angle and there would be less leverage, but the design was inherently faulty because the body flexed too much for the weight of the screen (I checked various level surfaces to be sure).
This was exacerbated by the fact that the screen dropped back behind the computer, thus moving the centre of gravity even further back (as opposed to a "top hinge" type like the aforementioned Elitebook, which shows not an iota of flex after four years of constant use). Obviously this was just going to get worse with time, so I applied for a Return Authority.
Now, I could go on and on about the trials and tribulations I suffered before I got my refund, but suffice to say that they basically didn't believe me and there were umpteen emails and phonecalls over about two weeks which just wore me out, but I stuck to my guns. I don't think I would ever again buy such an expensive item from a supplier not based in NZ - you're just too vulnerable if things go wrong.
I personally would never buy another Dell product.
Posted by chainey at 17:56:42 on January 5, 2013
How to choose the best tablet for you
101 great websites:
You haven't heard of yet
We ask the pros for building tips