Review: Modern Warfare 3

In the Fallout series, they say that war never changes. Perhaps it’s a more appropriate catchcry for the Modern Warfare series.

Chris Leggett | Monday, November 14 2011 | 4 Comments

Editors rating: Editor's rating: 3.5

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

Classification: R16
Platform: PC, Xbox 360, PS3
Test Platform: Xbox 360

Details

Developer: Infinity Ward, Sledgehammer Games; Publisher: Activision

Nicely dressed and seasoned, but this dish is getting old.

Editor's rating: 3.5



In the Fallout series, they say that war never changes. Perhaps it’s a more appropriate catchcry for the Modern Warfare series. It’s true that number three, the latest in the series, is an uncannily similar package to its predecessor, just as that game was to the original Modern Warfare before it. The question you’ll have to ask yourself is whether that's still good enough for you.

This stubborn refusal to upset the apple cart isn’t all bad. After the many potshots fired by EA, Modern Warfare 3’s campaign demonstrates that nobody does the cinematic, action-blockbuster military shooter quite like Infinity Ward. The action is only remotely within the realms of possibility, moving from one far-fetched, over-the-top scenario to the next. But war documentaries rarely pull punters to cinemas in droves – blockbuster action flicks do. And it’s something the minds behind the Call of Duty franchise know only too well.

Russia is at war with the US after the incidents of Modern Warfare 2’s notorious ‘No Russian’ level, where Soviet terrorists led by Vladimir Makarov frame the US for the death of dozens of Russian civilians. However, while the Russian president intends to make peace with his enemy, Makarov holds him to ransom in a bid to gain access to a nuclear arsenal and escalate the terrorists’ assault on the US.

Modern Warfare 3’s story excites from beginning to end, with more explosions, chase sequences, near-miss collisions and other heart-racing moments than even its predecessors. As such, it’s necessarily linear; the gameplay is generally all about moving your line forward, mowing down infinitely respawning enemies until you’ve secured a checkpoint. You’re afforded very little in the way of tactical opportunities. And although its glorified shooting galleries can sometimes feel rather shallow, it remains engaging nevertheless thanks to masterful pacing and adrenalin-pumping set pieces. Sure, all the staple sequences return – the gunship sections, the on-rails, vehicular gun-turret pieces and the breach-and-clear, slow-mo scenes – but Modern Warfare 3 riffs on them in relatively novel ways.

One area where the Modern Warfare experience has truly changed very little, though, is in its multiplayer component. Remember 2009’s Modern Warfare 2? That essentially forms the core of Modern Warfare 3’s offering, with new maps and only very subtle iterations. It’s generally all about fast gameplay on small- to medium-sized maps, and often boils down to who sees who first. It still looks nice enough, but the actual multiplayer gameplay is beginning to feel stale, particularly now that some killer competition has surfaced.

One bright spot in an otherwise repackaged multiplayer suite is the new Kill Confirmed mode; a variant on your standard Team Deathmatch formula. Not content with simply killing enemies, players must also recover their dog tags in order to add to the team’s score (thus “confirming” the kill). Similarly, you can also claim the tags of downed teammates to “deny” the enemy their kill. It places aggressors in sometimes precarious situations and forces a kind of tactical balance that’s previously been missing in the fast-and-loose Call of Duty multiplayer.

Making a welcome return is the Spec Ops mode: a collection of one-off missions that can be played cooperatively with a friend. The missions are rather varied, often open-ended, and sometimes assign quite different roles to the two players. Of particular note is the Firewall mission: while one player negotiates an area to reach a series of objectives, the second player provides cover by cycling through a number of turrets at different vantage points throughout the map. Also added to the Spec Ops roster is the now-obligatory Survival mode; it’s a nice addition that, disappointingly, supports only two players in this instance.

Sure, Modern Warfare 3’s perhaps the best Call of Duty yet in an iterative sense. But with a worthy challenger in Battlefield 3 nipping at its heels, this might just be the last time Activision gets away with such minor innovations.
4 Comments
Special Ops My flat mate bought this for his Xbox360, and ive got to say the special ops mode is way better than any other game mode, its really addictive, tactical and strategic. highly reccomend it. I havent played the campaign yet, i will wait until i get it for PC
Posted by Mohanz at 9:13:00 on November 15, 2011

Flag abuse

Modern Warfare 3 How long is the campaign, compared to Battlefield 3?
Posted by theoldfarter at 18:59:40 on November 14, 2011

Flag abuse

Modern Warfare 3 Overall depends on what difficulty your playing on. I play most of these FPS games on the hardest difficulty and therefore, takes me a bit longer to complete them. Takes +2 or so hours to complete the campaign on a harder difficulty (Not talking about MW3).
Posted by Brendon at 10:22:47 on November 29, 2011

Flag abuse

Modern Warfare 3 Hi, OldFarter :)

The campaign took me approximately 4 hours and 40 minutes to play through in its entirety on the default difficulty. I know a lot of people will think that's too short, but I didn't.

I'm afraid I'm uncertain as to how long Battlefield 3 took me to complete.
Posted by Chris Leggett at 9:27:01 on November 15, 2011

Flag abuse

Post a review
Listed as anonymous if blank

Comment composition options »

Allowable HTML: <!--break--> <a> <em> <i> <b> <strong> <pre> <u> <strike> <sub> <p> <table> <tr> <td> <thead> <tbody> <sup> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <br> <hr>
Line and paragraph breaks are recognised automatically.

CURRENT ISSUE
Newsletter & Subscriptions Windows vs. iOS vs. Android:
How to choose the best tablet for you

101 great websites:
You haven't heard of yet

DIY desktops:
We ask the pros for building tips

SIGN UP
PC World's weekly round-up of tech news, gear and game reviews, software selections, and handy How Tos.
Blogs
Hot Products

Hot Products || PC World editors iPhone 4S launch pics and unboxing
The iPhone 4S launched at midnight through both Vodafone and Telecom. ... READ MORE

Tux Love

Tux Love || Geoff Palmer Google : Starting to be evil?
Google recently deleted AdBlock Plus from its Android Play Store. This is ... READ MORE

Tech Guy

Tech Guy || Juha Saarinen Small balls of solder
The idea that desktops might change forever is enough to send geeks into a ... READ MORE

In a Nutshell

In a Nutshell || Zara Baxter Logging, not login
At an event in Singapore yesterday, Seamus Byrne, the editor of CNet ... READ MORE

Harley O'Gyver

Harley O'Gyver || Harley Ogier Pay for internet by-device? Not on my watch.
So as those of you who follow my twitterstream will know, I'm currently in ... READ MORE

The Arcade

The Arcade || PC World editors New Year, new games
You'er going to laugh. Or at the very least, you're going to scoff and ... READ MORE

Dumb Terminal Live!

Dumb Terminal Live! || PC World editors New Zealand memes: We think we're real funny
We New Zealanders love the internet, and we have a pretty good sense of ... READ MORE